The ever-candid Roy Keane remains sceptical about Manchester United’s form under the stewardship of Ruben Amorim, notwithstanding their Boxing Day triumph over Newcastle United by a solitary Patrick Dorgu volley. The victory propelled the Red Devils to fifth in the Premier League, yet concerns linger over their erratic displays.
The spectre of last season’s 15th-place finish underpins the current discourse, with Jamie Carragher and Keane united in their view that a Champions League berth appears elusive. Despite a substantial summer outlay, United’s campaign is marked by inconsistency, leaving a meagre seven-point buffer to 15th place.
Carragher remarked on Sky Sports: “A top-four finish feels ambitious. They must secure European competition, especially after their expenditure.”
Keane, mirroring this sentiment, pointed out: “Pre-season and signings were meant to elevate them. However, questions persist. They’re not ready for top-four contention.”
Keane further urged improvement: “Defensively, they’re lacking. Unless they become harder to break down, advancement will remain out of reach.”
Meanwhile, Amorim has underscored the importance of prudent planning for the impending January transfer window, seeking certainty in any prospective acquisition. Emphasizing a need to avoid previous errors, Amorim highlighted his approach: “We must be sure of our additions. It’s imperative not to repeat past mistakes. Stability is crucial, even amidst a challenging schedule.”
As the transfer window looms, the onus remains on Amorim to solidify a squad with which Keane, for one, is yet to be impressed.

